Fifth District Court of Appeal upholds dismissal in Sex Sting case today

Peter D Aiken
Sex Crime Lawyer

There was some good news in Sex Sting cases today. In a Brevard case, the appeals court has upheld the lower Court ruling dismissing a case in involving an attempted sex sting. The higher court affirmed the lower court without a detailed opinion. In this case, one I actually handled at the lower court, the undercover cop posted a profile on Plenty 0 Fish posing as a nineteen year old woman. The defendant, also on Plenty O Fish posted pretending to be a 25 year old man. Both were lying. They chatted for a while and ultimately, after some sexually explicit general questions, the defendant terminated contact and “blocked” further communication. The undercover detective (Spadafora) frustrated that the defendant would not meet, or even ask for sex then went to the defendants house, pretending to be looking for a girl gone missing after the chats. The defendant apologized simply saying no one believed it was real.
The judge at the hearing on the motion to dismiss commented that this was nothing more than two adults lying to each other. The defendant never asked to meet or travel. The undercover detective had posted a picture of an adult with an adult profile. In this case, there was no actual travel to meet and there was no real solicitation for sex. The undercover detective had posted a picture of an adult with an adult profile. In this case, there was no actual travel to meet and there was no real solicitation for sex.
The State was of the opinion that talking dirty is a crime, even if there is no real solicitation. Thank goodness the Court disagreed. After the dismissal by the lower Court, Michael Gelety handled the appeal and the defendant finally prevailed. It took two years but in the long run, justice did prevail. As a sex sting lawyer, it is encouraging to see that finally some of the appeal Courts are getting a handle on what the police are really doing. Our thanks to Jason Hicks a spectacular Brevard criminal defense lawyer whose hard work and diligence set up the legal issues, and Michael Fayard a Sarasota lawyer whose research greatly contributed to our success. It was a great team effort start to finish. There has been a dramatic decrease in the number of sex stings in Florida. Now, instead of big operations with “take down” houses the police are working smaller individual cases. Many of the investigations now focus on child porn. Grady Judd is still however running stings, now targeting prostitution. My bet is that the world’s oldest profession will outlast Grady Judd. Prostitution has been here since the beginning of time and before. Female Chimpanzees are known to trade sex for food and favors. Maybe when Grady Judd runs out of people to arrest he can go after the monkeys.
If you want to talk about a sex sting arrest, call a sex crime lawyer

In 2015 Orange County Sheriff Sued Over 2011 Sex Sting Arrest

Peter D Aiken
The Sex Offender Defender

A man had his case thrown out in Orange County and has filed a lawsuit against the Sheriff in Orange County. He was arrested in a sex sting and clearly entrapped. The State Court Judge dismissed the case when it was shown that he clearly never intended to solicit or have sex with a minor. The police basically tricked him. He was not able to see his kids for over two years. He lost his job and was subjected to terrible publicity and disgraced. As his attorney said, most people will always look at him as a sex offender although he clearly did nothing wrong.

It is going to take a Federal lawsuit to reign in some of the outrageous police misconduct. This appears to be the first one so far in Florida. Some of the State Court judges are finally showing the courage to throw out a few of the cases. It is going to take a judgment against the Sheriff to finally wake up people like Grady Judd. So far, there has been no downside for law enforcement. If a judge later throws out an arrest, it is simply no big deal. Now, if they get sued, and if they lose, they may temper some of their terrible entrapment techniques.

The Orange County case was one of the ones that started on

Over and over the man indicated he was not interested in sex with a minor. It was classic bait and switch. Only when he showed up to meet the adult woman at her “home” was the fact that there were three of them mentioned. It was absolute trickery by the police.As a sex crime lawyer, I wish this man good luck. It will be years before the case is decided, but it is about time someone has taken on the system. To win a lawsuit against the police, you really need the perfect set of facts. Filing a lawsuit and winning it are two different things. You still have to convince a jury to return a verdict for a serious amount to make it worth while. We all wish him luck.

Related Article with Video:

Man arrested in Orange County Sex Sting sues over Arrests